In an outcome that nobody could have predicted, the residents of Gauteng have rejected the draft bill on Expropriation without Compensation.
This follows a process of round-table discussions with stakeholders, social media and newspaper notices calling for input, and public hearings across the province. This took place between April and August this year.
The process of expropriation is not in dispute since it takes place in most countries around the world where land is expropriated to build infrastructure for service delivery. What has been a major concern in South Africa is the proposal to expropriate without compensating the person or entity being expropriated. This is an attack on private property rights and a red flag for investors, which will undoubtedly cost jobs and negatively impact the economy.
Gauteng’s Department of Infrastructure Development, under whose auspices the bill is being driven through the public participation process, met to consider all the inputs and formulate a consolidated Gauteng position. This position made several amendments to the Expropriation Bill.
Key amongst these was an amendment proposed by the Democratic Alliance (DA), which removes the clause allowing for nil compensation of private property and replaces it with a clause that allows for nil compensation only in the case of state-owned land that is not required for service delivery.
The bill will only be passed into law if approved with the concurrence of five provinces. Based on its rejection of nil compensation, Gauteng will not, for now, be one of the provinces that supports the original bill passed by Parliament. This can change as the process unfolds since Gauteng’s position can be rejected by the NCOP. In that case, Gauteng’s Infrastructure Development Committee would reconsider the Gauteng position.
Gauteng is the financial heart of the country. Significantly, its citizens understand and recognise the damage that expropriation with no compensation will do to the economy.









